Skip to content

Directors in the Firing Line: Personal Liability for Employment Standards Breaches

The Employment Relations Authority's decision in Guo v Su's Investment Ltd [2026] NZERA 496 highlights when directors may be personally liable for unpaid employee entitlements and the importance of complying with directors' duties under the Companies Act 1993.

Overview

In Guo v Su’s Investment Ltd [2026] NZERA 496, the Employment Relations Authority (the Authority) considered whether the directors of a failed company could be held personally liable for employment-related obligations that remained unpaid following a prior determination in favour of an employee.

The Authority determined the directors could be held personally liable for breaches of minimum employment standards where there was meaningful involvement. The case highlights the intersection between employment law obligations and directors’ duties under the Companies Act 1993.

Background

The Authority previously determined that Haochen Guo was unjustifiably dismissed and unjustifiably disadvantaged by Su’s Investment Limited (SIL), which operated the Coffee Studio café in Hamilton. The earlier determination awarded Mr Guo:

  1. $25,000 compensation for humiliation, loss of dignity and injury to feelings;
  2. $2,784 gross lost remuneration;
  3. $1,648 gross unpaid holiday pay; and
  4. a $500 penalty payable to the Crown.

Following the determination, SIL ceased trading and failed to satisfy the awards. Evidence before the Authority established that the company had substantial outstanding liabilities, including obligations owed to Inland Revenue, and lacked sufficient assets to meet its debts.

The company’s directors were Shaolan Su and Wenzhong Su. The evidence established that Ms Su was responsible for the day-to-day management and operation of the business, whereas Mr Su was a passive director who did not participate in operational or employment-related decision-making.

Issues

The Authority was required to determine:

  1. Whether leave should be granted under s 142Y of the Employment Relations Act 2000 (the Act) to allow Mr Guo to recover monies personally from one or both directors; and
  2. Whether compliance orders should be issued against the directors requiring them to ensure compliance with the earlier Authority determination.

Decision

The Authority held that only the unpaid holiday pay qualified as “wages or other money payable” for the purposes of section 142Y of the Act. The compensation award and lost remuneration arising from the personal grievance claim did not fall within the statutory category of employment-standard debts recoverable from individuals involved in the breach.

The Authority distinguished between the two directors. Mr Su was found to be a passive director who had no meaningful involvement in the management of the business or the employment relationship. There was insufficient evidence to establish that he was a person “involved in a breach” of employment standards as defined by section 142W of the Act.

In contrast, Ms Su exercised effective managerial control over the company, was responsible for employment matters, and had knowledge of the outstanding holiday pay entitlement owing to Mr Guo. Accordingly, she was found to be a person involved in the breach of an employment standard per section 142W of the Act.

The Authority therefore granted leave to Mr Guo to recover the unpaid holiday pay of $1,648.00 gross personally from Ms Su.

Compliance Orders

Although the Authority possessed jurisdiction to issue compliance orders against directors, it declined to do so in this instance. The evidence demonstrated that:

  1. SIL had ceased trading;
  2. the directors had not transferred or dissipated company assets for personal benefit;
  3. Ms Su was unemployed; and
  4. neither director possessed practical means to fund the company to satisfy the outstanding awards.

The Authority therefore exercised its discretion against making personal compliance orders. However, compliance orders were made requiring SIL to satisfy the existing awards and requiring Ms Su to pay the outstanding holiday pay personally if SIL failed to do so within the stipulated period.

Employment Law Significance

This decision reinforces several important principles:

  1. Minimum employment standards receive heightened statutory protection.
  2. Directors who actively manage a business and control employment decisions are at greater risk of personal liability than passive directors.
  3. The corporate veil will not necessarily shield directors from personal accountability where they are directly involved in employment standards breaches.
  4. Insolvency or business closure does not automatically extinguish liability for unpaid statutory employee entitlements.
  5. Holiday pay, wages, minimum wage obligations, and other statutory entitlements may be recoverable from individuals involved in the breach under the Employment Relations Act.

Conclusion

Guo v Su’s Investment Ltd [2026] NZERA 496 demonstrates the willingness of the Authority to impose personal liability on directors who are actively involved in breaches of minimum employment standards. While the Authority respected the principle of separate legal personality by declining broader personal enforcement against the directors, it nevertheless held that the managing director, Ms Su, could be personally liable for unpaid holiday pay because of her direct involvement in the breach.

This article is current as at the date of publication and is only intended to provide general comments about the law. Harkness Henry accepts no responsibility for reliance by any person or organisation on the content of the article. Please contact the author of the article if you require specific advice about how the law applies to you.

For further information

Evoto

Nicole Cutler

Hamilton office

Level 8, KPMG Centre
85 Alexandra Street
Hamilton 3204
Private Bag 3077
Hamilton 3240
New Zealand
DX GP 20015

+64 7 838 2399

Auckland office

Level One, 5 Broadway
Newmarket,
Auckland 1023
PO Box 9892
Newmarket,
Auckland 1149
New Zealand
DX CP 31010

+64 9 367 2001

Cambridge office

57 Queen Street
PO Box 3
Cambridge 3450
New Zealand
DX GA 27516

+64 7 827 5111

Paeroa office

2 Queen Street
Paeroa 3600
Private Bag 3077
Hamilton 3240
New Zealand

+64 7 862 8803

Matamata office

2 Arawa Street
Cooper Aitken Building
Matamata 3400
Private Bag 3077
Hamilton 3240
New Zealand

+64 7 838 2399
Back To Top