Skip to content

Separation – A Key Consideration

This article touches on a topic that sadly for many Kiwis, is a familiar story. The legal definition of "separation" under New Zealand law, specifically in the context of the division of relationship and separate property. It outlines the relevant statutory framework under the Property (Relationships) Act 1976 and discusses key Court interpretations that clarify when a relationship is considered to have ended for property division purposes.

For many people going through relationship change, it is important to know key legal concepts and how they impact on you and your family. Some basic fundamentals and the understanding of how they fit with you is important in terms of managing change.

The Law

Under the Property (Relationships) Act 1976, a relationship ends at the point at which spouses or partners cease to live together as a couple. This is a factual determination, requiring both physical separation and a mental attitude adverse to continuing the relationship.

The date of separation can be critical particularly in terms of property classification as either relationship property (to be divided) or separate property (to be retained by the individual).

The courts have developed a two-part test—physical separation and mental intent—to assess whether separation has occurred, with strong evidence required in cases where parties continue to reside under the same roof.

You don’t need an Order of the Court to be separated. Separation is just that – parties separating. The Court can give a Separation Order although most couples don’t get one.

The Act & The Courts

  1. Legislative Definition of Separation
    1. For marriages and civil unions, the Property (Relationships) Act 1976 provides that a marriage or civil union ends if the parties cease to live together as a married or civil union couple, the marriage or civil union is dissolved, or one party dies.
    2. For de facto relationships, the relationship ends if the partners cease to live together as a couple or one partner dies.
  2. Judicial Interpretation of Separation
    1. The Courts have held that living apart requires both a physical separation and a mental attitude averse to cohabitation on the part of one or both spouses. A recent Family Court case (Zampino v Zampino) looked specifically at these aspects.
    2. Strong evidence is required to demonstrate separation where parties continue to live under the same roof.
    3. The determination is fact-specific and considers the parties’ conduct and intentions.
  3. Effect on Property Classification
    1. Upon separation, each party is entitled to an equal share of relationship property, which includes the family home, family chattels, and other property acquired during the relationship
    2. Property acquired after separation is generally classified as separate property. This is why determining when separation occurred is very important. It can have a significant bearing on who is entitled to what in the final division of your property.
    3. The court retains discretion to treat post-separation property as relationship property in certain circumstances.

What Does the Above Mean?

The Property (Relationships) Act 1976 establishes the legislative framework for determining when relationships end. Further, it provides rules and requirements in terms of how the division of property is to proceed.

The Courts have taken the legislation and provided its interpretation as it applies to the facts of people’s lives.  What this means is that there are some lessons that we can all benefit from when it comes time to move on to the next chapter in our lives.

  1. You need to be living separately for at least 2 years before you can apply for a dissolution of your marriage. So, showing the Court you have been apart for 2 years is a legal requirement in this regard.
  2. If you are in a de facto relationship that has ended and you need to seek Orders of the Court in terms of the division of property, you must apply within 3 years following separation. Knowing the separation date can be crucial.
  3. Post separation property may well be your separate property. If you receive property after separation, the assumed starting point is that it is your separate property and your ex-partner has no claim to a half share of it. So, determining when you separated is important for this determination.
  4. Property has Value – determining the value of property on separation can be key particularly if you have contributed significantly to asset value after you have parted ways. Also, if you have reduced debt following separation, you might seek this to be taken into account to your benefit.

What To Do

If you are in the process of considering separation, it is best to take legal advice as to your position. Speaking to a legal expert who can provide good advice given your specific set of circumstances is a smart move. Without proper advice, the possible negative consequences can be significant.

As the date of separation can be crucial for determining which property is subject to equal sharing and which remains separate, parties should carefully document the circumstances of their separation as this might be central to any subsequent relationship property dispute. Proper records, diary notes and effective communication can be critical later on down the track.

This article is current as at the date of publication and is only intended to provide general comments about the law. Harkness Henry accepts no responsibility for reliance by any person or organisation on the content of the article. Please contact the author of the article if you require specific advice about how the law applies to you.

For further information

PAG2

Paul Gascoigne

Hamilton office

Level 8, KPMG Centre
85 Alexandra Street
Hamilton 3204
Private Bag 3077
Hamilton 3240
New Zealand
DX GP 20015

+64 7 838 2399

Auckland office

Level One, 5 Broadway
Newmarket,
Auckland 1023
PO Box 9892
Newmarket,
Auckland 1149
New Zealand
DX CP 31010

+64 9 367 2001

Cambridge office

57 Queen Street
PO Box 3
Cambridge 3450
New Zealand
DX GA 27516

+64 7 827 5111

Paeroa office

2 Queen Street
Paeroa 3600
Private Bag 3077
Hamilton 3240
New Zealand

+64 7 862 8803

Matamata office

2 Arawa Street
Cooper Aitken Building
Matamata 3400
Private Bag 3077
Hamilton 3240
New Zealand

+64 7 838 2399
Back To Top